Joe investigates

Dissident revolt - the 2010 dirty protest
JOE speaks to Gary Donnelly, a former prisoner in Northern Ireland's high-security facility at Maghaberry, about a shocking, largely unnoticed protest by republican dissidents that erupted inside the prison ealier this year.
"The toilets were broken so we had to keep our excrement in plastic bags," recalls Garry Donnelly, a republican from the Creggan area of Derry of his time in detention in a Northern Ireland prison. "But we had no way of getting rid of it. We were forced to liquefy the waste and pour it out through the sides of the cell doors."
It sounds like an account from inside the H-Blocks during the darkest days of the dirty protest Provisional IRA prisoners engaged in during the height of the Troubles. Except this happened in summer 2010.
According to the Prison Service of Northern Ireland there are currently 30 republican prisoners detained in the high security facility at Maghaberry. Although largely unnoticed by the media in the Republic, the men spent much of 2010 locked into a bitter dispute with the prison authorities.
Prisoners detained on charges relating to paramilitary activity won the right to be segregated from the rest of Maghaberry's prison population back in 2005 after a lengthy protest led by men linked to the 'Real' IRA. However, the tension began to mount earlier this year amid claims of 23-hour lock downs, inhumane treatment and attacks on prisoners.
Detained
Among those detained was Gary Donnelly, whose role in the dispute started back in August 2006. He and eight other members of the 'Derry Anti-War Coalition' broke into the Raytheon factory in Derry after information emerged that the facility was being used to make missiles for Israeli and US forces. "We thrashed the place and threw their computers out the window," recalls Donnelly.
The group, tagged the Raytheon Nine, was arrested at the scene. While being taken into court in handcuffs, Donnelly says he turned to wave at supporters when PSNI offers bundled him to the ground. "I was assaulted and carried into the court yet they charged me with the assault of three officers," he says.
Although later acquitted of charges relating to the Raytheon factory break-in, Donnelly had to appear in court again to face the triple assault charge. He faced a lengthy prison term.
However, a journalist from the Irish News, Seamus McKinney, witnessed the event and came forward. The presiding judge, Judge Bates, said he had been "impressed" by Mr McKinney's evidence and then threw out the case.
Just hours after winning his court battle on assault charges against members of the PSNI, Donnelly was stopped again. "That night I was in Foyle Street in central Derry with three members of the Raytheon Nine. The PSNI pulled up and one of them told me to get on the footpath so he could search me.
I was pushed face down onto the ground and one came down with his knee - and snapped my arm.
"I said he could search me where I was. He shoved me and as I went back he went to shove me again. I stumbled and two or three others jumped me. I was pushed face down onto the ground and one came down with his knee - and snapped my arm."
Donnelly says he asked for an ambulance to be called but the officers refused, handcuffing him and taking him to station. "They didn't deny handcuffing me in the trial. They eventually un-cuffed one of my wrists but left the cuff on the broken arm," he recalls.
The republican was released into the custody of his solicitor some time later and was taken to hospital. "My arm was wrecked. They x-rayed me and found that it was broken in three places - I had a three-piece spiral fracture."
Worse was yet to come. Donnelly was again charged with assaulting an officer. Presiding over the case was District Judge Barney McElholm. He acknowledged that there were a number of discrepancies in the evidence given by police officers during the trial, adding, "It surprises me somewhat that no-one took seriously enough Mr. Donnelly's protestations that his arm was broken." He pointed out that the circumstances surrounding how Donnelly sustained a broken arm were "unresolved and unclear" before finding him guilty of assaulting one of the officers.
"I was given a £400 fine but on a point of principal I appealed it." Donnelly's appeal was unsuccessful. He was given a seven month custodial sentence.
High-security
Donnelly was sent to the high-security prison at Maghaberry to begin his sentence. He was detained for a week alongside ordinary criminals before being moved to Roe House - the most high-security wing of the prison reserved for republican dissidents. "The cell doors only ever opened when there was a minimum of three prison officers to accompany you," remembers Donnelly. "It was like something out of The Silence of the Lambs."
The controlled movement of republican prisoners around the wing meant that for the next three-and-a-half months, Donnelly never passed any other prisoners or entered anyone else's cell. He points out, "You were lucky to get showered and fed, never mind an opportunity to mix with others."
The situation in the republican wing of the prison was already beginning to escalate at the time of Donnelly's arrival. Republicans were refusing to eat in their cells because each one also contained a toilet. "It was like eating in a bathroom, so they refused to do it," Donnelly says.
The prison authorities eventually ceded to the demand. "They would take us into a small kitchen one at a time," Donnelly recalls. "We worked out that prisoners had approximately four minutes to eat their meal if everyone was to get out to eat but the prison officers deliberately slowed the process down so a lot of prisoners didn't get fed.
"The evening meal came at 4pm so if you missed that you wouldn't be fed until 8am the next morning. It meant that for sometimes three or four days in a row guys were getting their last meal of the day at 12pm."
One day a group of prison officers came to Donnelly's cell and said his life had been placed under threat by one of the dissident republican groups, and they moved him to the isolation wing of the prison - the Special Secure Unit (SSU).
Despite this, there are elements of what Mr Donnelly was claiming which, through investigation, could be verified.
For example, his initial arrest during which his arm was broken in three places is a matter of public record. As is the fact that he was later charged with assaulting three PSNI officers while wearing handcuffs and that the accounts given in court were rubbished by the judge who then dismissed the case.
Donnelly also made claims about stop and search legislation being used by the PSNI to harass republicans and their families. Again, through a bit of digging, I found stats on stop and searches - the PSNI carried out 17,000 in six months. Set that against security estimations of the numerical strength of violent republican groups (apparently around 200 in the Real IRA) and there certainly seems to be something to the claim.
Overall, we know Donnelly had his arm broken during an arrest. We know a judge highlighted farcical discrepancies in the accounts given by three PSNI officers who say he assaulted them when he was being brought into court in handcuffs. We also know for a fact that the PSNI searched 17,000 people while investigating the actions of an estimated 200 people. Since the article has been published, we also now know that the latest round of charges – possession of an article likely to be of use to terrorists (a mobile phone) have just been dropped. All this, I would suggest, at least entitles Donnelly the right to tell his side of the story.
I’d add that although these events and accusations are exactly what dissidents want to see in the media, because it’s in line with their narrative of a British occupation with an accompanying malignant security apparatus, that doesn’t make it propaganda or something not worth highlighting. In other words, you can be horrified by Omagh and still say cases of the PSNI hauling people into court on fake assault charges should be written about.
Thanks again for your feedback.