Search icon

Movies & TV

09th May 2021

Who killed Erin in Mare of Easttown? We list the suspects from least to most likely

Rory Cashin

We’re halfway through the season, so it is time to start weeding out the murderer.

We’re three episodes into the seven-episode miniseries Mare Of Easttown, and we’re sure it will go down alongside Big Little Lies, Sharp Objects, and The Undoing in terms of must-watch, propulsive, addictive, and incredibly well-acted murder mysteries.

Kate Winslet is delivering a career-high performance as the detective in the small town – seriously, her accent work in this is some of the best since Frances McDormand in Fargo – and she’s surrounded by a stellar supporting cast all bringing their A-game.

However, at least one of those cast members is also the killer at the centre of the show’s mystery, and we figured now is as good a time as any to start going through the suspects, from least to most likely of being the murderer, staring with…

Kenny McMenamin (Patrick Murney)

Being an angry and abusive father who screams about spending his money on his own grandchild and then blames Erin for his dinner being too hot, Kenny was an immediate suspect. But then he went on a solo manhunt to take out the person he believed killed his daughter (see below), so it seems incredibly unlikely that he would’ve tried to kill someone if he himself was the killer? Although he is also prone to blackout-drunk sessions, so he can’t be ruled out entirely.

Dylan Hinchey (Jack Mulhern)

As Erin’s ex, Dylan is immediately unlikeable, seemingly taking split custody of their young child from Erin more out of spite than actual love. He also seems to be more of a teenage douchebag than an actual killer, although he did just stand by while his new girlfriend (see below) set up a violent catfishing expedition on poor Erin. Maybe if he found out earlier than he’s letting on that he wasn’t actually the baby’s father, that could be the catalyst for the murder, but after being shot by Kenny while pleading for him to listen to reason, it seems more and more unlikely that he killed Erin.

Brianna Del Rasso (Mackenize Lansing)

The only person on the show who is more unlikeable that Dylan, compounding that dislike after beating Erin up on camera by making some horrible remarks about Mare’s dead son. She does seem almost too obvious to be the killer, but that was the exact same mistake we all made with The Undoing, and look where that got us.

Siobhan Sheehan (Angourie Rice)

What’s going on, Siobhan? Why didn’t you tell your own mother that you may well have been the last person to see Erin alive before she disappeared into the woods? What is with that weird podcast about your brother who committed suicide? Why do you seem to be the only character the show is devoting time to that isn’t directly involved with Erin’s murder investigation? The only thing stopping us from suspecting you even more is that if it does turn out to be you (or maybe you AND your band mates) is that it would be startlingly similar to another great, recent HBO murder mystery series headed by an Oscar magnet actress.

Father Dan Hastings (Neal Huff)

As the show is prone to tell us over and over again, everyone is related to everyone else in Easttown. So it would make for a nice narrative bow for Mare’s own cousin to be the killer, and it would also make sense as to why Deacon Burton (see below) might be helping him cover it all up. The only thing is… Why? Why would Father Dan kill Erin? We suppose he wouldn’t necessarily need to give a reason, but so far the show hasn’t given us a connective tissue between Dan and Erin.

Frank Sheehan (David Denman)

He already lied (and was subsequently caught out) about not knowing Erin, so what else could he be lying about? Could he really have been having a relationship with Erin? Will the DNA results prove that he was actually the baby’s father? He seemed willing enough to prove his innocence, so he might be in the clear, but it still doesn’t explain why he lied at all.

Deacon Mark Burton (James McArdle)

We literally see him taking Erin’s bike from the back of his car and dumping it in the river. He has arrived suddenly in the town, having been moved from another parish, which sets off alarm bells for the detectives. He’s also not answering the door when they come knocking to ask questions, and his phone was the last call made from Erin’s phone before she died. So the show really wants you to think he did it. Which probably means he didn’t do it. Also, we don’t actually know that it was Erin who made that call at the end, and maybe the Deacon is just trying to help someone else in the town out of their situation. Which, y’know, is also pretty bad.

John Ross or Billy Ross (Joe Tippett or Robbie Tann)

Kenny’s drinking buddies, and also good pals with Frank (they took that passed out photo of him on the night of the murder, which also proves that they weren’t passed out), they’ve been on the periphery of the events throughout. There was also something a bit off about that scene where they delivered the news to Kenny about his dead daughter. Either one of them did it, and the other helped cover it up – and maybe dumped the bike near the Deacon’s house to divert attention and blame – or they are both naturally very suspicious acting at all times.

Richard Ryan (Guy Pearce)

Maybe it is because it Guy Pearce playing him, but we can’t not discount the new-in-town lecturer. Sure, he hooked up with Mare the night it happened, but remember she was asleep in her own bed when she got the call about Erin, leaving plenty of time for Richard to head into the woods and do the killing. Maybe it will all make for a great story around his next book, because we know he’s still smarting about being a bit of an unsuccessful author. Listen, we don’t want it to be him, because we want good things for Mare, but it would also be just her luck that the first guy she properly likes in years is a murderer.

The trailer for the fourth episode below seems to indicate we’re about to learn a lot more about everyone involved. It will arrive on NOW on Monday, 10 May.

Clip via Movie Lounge

LISTEN: You Must Be Jokin’ with Aideen McQueen – Faith healers, Coolock craic and Gigging as Gaeilge