
Share
12th February 2023
12:48pm GMT

USA Today reported that the prosecution's case hinged entirely on the complainants identifying Smith from a photo array, as there was no other evidence linking Smith to the supposed crime, and no one else was charged.
In June 2001, Smith was granted a new trial, with Fairfield County Common Pleas Judge Richard E. Berens ruling that prosecutors had withheld evidence that suggested the crime never occurred.
All charges were later dropped against Smith.
Smith's lawyer, Joseph Landusky, told Local 12: "He (Smith) was sentenced to 67 years in prison for a crime that was not even committed by anyone."
He continued: "When first responders showed up (at the supposed crime scene), there were no footprints in the snow. It had recently snowed.
"There was a dog barking right next door when they pulled up, the neighbours said no dog had barked in the last hour.
"There were no tire tracks, so it made sense to the investigating officers that this didn’t even happen.
"When they went in and checked the house out, they wrote in their report that it was too selective for them."
He added: "These are written in these reports. These reports were not given to the defence lawyer."
Smith is now pursuing a federal lawsuit against the Pickerington police detective who investigated his case, the city of Pickerington and Fairfield County, depositions for which are said to be ongoing.