Search icon

Sport

03rd Jun 2015

Ireland v England: Who makes JOE’s 1995 & 2015 combined XIs?

Who makes it into our sides?

JOE

Ireland host England this weekend for the first time in 20 years.

Much has been said about England’s last trip to Dublin, but to be honest, we’d rather leave that awful night in the past and talk about the football instead.

Both sides had some star players lining out on the Landsdowne turf that evening, but how many of them would make it into their country’s current starting XI?

We’ve picked a combined XI for each country based on the starting line-up from that game and the starting side in each of their last competitive games.

Here’s what we’ve gone with.

Ireland combined XI 1995 & 2015

GK: Shay Given

Alan Kelly was a great servant to Ireland, but on his day, Given is world-class.

given1

LB: Denis Irwin

Robbie Brady is occasionally brilliant. Denis Irwin was constantly fantastic.

irw

RB: Seamus Coleman

The Donegal man is probably Ireland’s best player at the moment and gets the nod ahead of Terry Phelan.

England v Republic of Ireland - International Friendly

CB: John O’Shea

The hero of Gelsenkirchen fits in nicely.

John O'Shea celebrates after the game 14/10/2014

CB: Paul McGrath

An automatic selection for Ireland’s best ever defender.

Ooh ahh

LM: Jonathan Walters

Walters gets the nod ahead of forgotten man Eddie McGoldrick.

Jonathan Walters with Maciej Rybus and Kamil Glik 29/3/2015

RM: Steve Staunton

The gaffer is our choice for the right-side of midfield. A consistent performer who always gave his all.

The Gaffer and Roberto Donadoni

CM: Andy Townsend

Before Townsend became the worst commentator the world has ever seen, he was a top-class midfielder and captain for Ireland.

Andy Townsend Republic of Ireland World Cup 18/6/1994

CM: James McCarthy

Gets in ahead of John Sheridan because of his natural talent and the player he will be, rather than the one he currently is.

James McCarthy and Nemanja Matic 5/3/2014

CF: Niall Quinn

The big man gets the nod ahead of David Kelly and Wes Hoolahan because we would only love to see the likes of himself lining out alongside Robbie.

NiallQuinn11

ST: Robbie Keane

He’s Ireland’s greatest ever goalscorer, so he’s an automatic choice alongside Quinny.

Robbie Keane frustrated 29/3/2015

England combined XI 1995 & 2015

GK: David Seaman 

A tight call between Seaman and Joe Hart, but the former Arsenal stopper gets in for consistency.

FUSSBALL: EURO 1996 ESP - ENG 2:4 n.E.

LB: Leighton Baines

We’ve gone for Baines over Graeme Le Saux because the Everton player’s set-piece delivery is nothing short of outstanding.

England v Ireland - International Friendly

RB: Warren Barton 

Maybe in a few years we might have a different view, but at the moment Nathaniel Clyne hasn’t done enough to dislodge the former Newcastle player.

warbart

CB: Gary Cahill

Cahill or Gary Pallister was probably the toughest decision we had to make, but the former United man wasn’t the same player for his country as he was for his club.

Meanwhile, Cahill has become England’s number one defender.

Uruguay v England: Group D - 2014 FIFA World Cup Brazil

CB: Tony Adams 

Adams gets the other centre-half slot. One of the best defenders of a generation and definitely one of the toughest.

tony

LM: Raheem Sterling 

The controversial Liverpool player would make it into most sides for his pace and footballing intelligence.

LONDON, ENGLAND - MARCH 05:  Raheem Sterling of England in action during the International Friendly match between England and Denmark at Wembley Stadium on March 5, 2014 in London, England.  (Photo by Clive Rose/Getty Images)

RM: Darren Anderton 

The former Spurs player would have had a much finer career if he wasn’t made mostly out of glass. A fantastic player who was ravaged by injuries.

DarrenAnderton_News_Main

CM: Paul Ince 

Acted as an enforcer for Man United, Milan and Liverpool. Too good to leave out.

ince

CM: David Platt 

We think 27 goals in 62 appearances speaks for itself.

14 Jun 1992:  David Platt of England leaves the French defence on the floor during the European Championship Group 1 match at the Malmo Stadium in Malmo, Sweden. The match ended in a 0-0 draw.  Mandatory Credit: Simon Bruty /Allsport

CF: Wayne Rooney 

The current squad’s most naturally talented player. An automatic selection.

England v Italy - UEFA EURO 2012 Quarter Final

CF: Alan Shearer

An extraordinary goalscorer, Shearer could do it for club and country. A phenomenal player.

shea

Combined starting XIs

So there you have it, JOE’s combined eleven. Go see some of the stars of both teams this Sunday, June 7th in the Aviva. Click here to purchase tickets. #MakeTheMatch